Nash Holos: Yana Rathman and Memories of Babyn Yar
Today we have a special story for our listeners, a story that transcends time and generations. A story from the heart. And a story that reminds us of the powerful role that memory plays in our lives.
Yana Rathman is an educator and activist in the Jewish community of San Francisco. She recently traveled to Ukraine. Here, in her own words, are some of her reflections.
“He was tall, with broad shoulders, olive skin, and a full head of black hair. He joined the Soviet army in the first days of the war with Nazi Germany. He was seriously wounded twice, and finished the war by signing his name on the Reichstag wall in Berlin in May 1945. However, when he returned home to the Ukrainian capital of Kyiv, there was no one there to greet him. His entire family—including his young wife and two young daughters—had been killed at the ravine of Babyn Yar. They were among the nearly 34,000 Jews—mostly women, children and the elderly—shot by the Nazis over the course of three days in late September 1941.
It is considered one of the largest massacres of the Holocaust. Estimates indicate that more than 100,000 people were killed in this ravine during the course of the occupation.
Grandpa Yaakov was my dad’s stepfather. He married my grandmother a few years after the war, when my dad was already a teenager. Grandpa Yaakov had no more children after the war, so from the moment I was born, I became the apple of his eye, and we always had a very special bond. I knew that he would do anything I asked, with two exceptions. He would never wear his war medals, and he would never go to the annual Victory Day parade with me.
We didn’t speak about Babyn Yar in my grandfather’s presence. Every September he would go to Babyn Yar with a group of Jewish men to read Kaddish. He risked being arrested, but nothing we said would stop him.
As a child, I tried to comprehend the dark facts of this tragedy. I convinced myself that at least his children, cute little girls who were only three and five years old, could not have been shot. I dreamed many times that they must have been hidden somewhere. We just needed to find them.
As I grew up in Kyiv I was haunted by the past, and I wanted answers. Why were the Soviets so afraid of this place? Why were they so afraid of any memory of this tragedy? Why wouldn’t they create a proper memorial? After all, it wasn’t the communists who committed these crimes. Weren’t they the ones fighting the Nazis?
I didn’t receive adequate answers to these questions during my Soviet upbringing. It was never discussed at school or in the media. My grandfather passed away in Kyiv, in 1986.
After years of delay, my family immigrated to the United States in 1989 and focused on building new lives.”
Yana Rathman had left Ukraine, but the demons of history continued to haunt her.
“I visited Kyiv several times after Ukraine got its independence in 1991. Several monuments were finally placed at Babyn Yar, but there were no information signs, and the place was littered with garbage. The young people I met there were casually sipping beer, oblivious to the immense mass grave beneath their feet. I always left that place with a heavy heart.
This year marks the 75th anniversary of the tragic events of September 1941. Because of my involvement with Jewish Community Federation of San Francisco and Limmud, I was invited to attend a series of Babyn Yar commemorative events that took place in Kyiv on September 23-29, 2016. This was my first visit to Ukraine after the tumultuous events of the Maidan, and the start of the war with Russia.
The Babyn Yar commemoration schedule features lectures with a wide range of topics. The panels were expertly moderated, painful moments in the history of Ukrainian and Jewish relations were openly discussed, and a variety of opinions were represented.
There was an official memorial ceremony at the Babyn Yar site where President Petro Poroshenko spoke about Babyn Yar as first and foremost a Jewish tragedy, but also a Ukrainian tragedy. And I saw many young residents of Kyiv come to the site with flowers.
For me personally, the most touching event was a presentation of school projects dedicated to educating children about the Holocaust. The large auditorium at the Ministry of Education was packed with teachers who travelled to Kyiv from towns and small villages all over Ukraine, some from places right near the warzone in eastern Ukraine. One teacher slipped out secretly from Russian-occupied Crimea. One after another the teachers spoke about the importance of educating a new generation of Ukrainian children about the lessons of the Holocaust and promoting an atmosphere of tolerance. Every project demonstrated how these teachers create meaningful experiences for their students in order to make them feel and understand the consequences of intolerance, hate and indifference.
As I walked along the same cobblestone streets of old Kyiv that I once took to ballet lessons with my grandfather Yaakov many years ago, I couldn’t stop thinking about how I would have wanted him to know about these changes. I believe that the changes that I witnessed are a direct consequence of the Ukrainian people choosing a free and democratic society, and reflect a new set of values adopted by the post-soviet generation. But I also understand that these changes are not happening all by themselves. I feel very grateful to the educators, activists, and organizations, like the Ukrainian Jewish Encounter, that have worked so hard and continue working in Ukraine to advance this noble cause.
Many of us who immigrated to the U.S. because of the horrible experiences of antisemitism are often quick to stereotype and focus on the past. But the long road to reconciliation and mutual understanding starts today. Let’s not miss it.”
We want to thank Yana Rathman for sharing her thoughts with our listeners.
This has been Ukrainian Jewish Heritage on Nash Holos Ukrainian Roots Radio. From San Francisco, I’m Peter Bejger. Until next time, shalom!
Listen to the program here.
Ukrainian Jewish Heritage is brought to you by the Ukrainian Jewish Encounter based in Toronto, Ontario. To find out more about their work, visit their website and follow them on Facebook and Twitter. Transcripts and audio files of this and earlier broadcasts of Ukrainian Jewish Heritage are available at their website as well as at the Nash Holos website.